Spend even a few minutes perusing the world of personal finance, and you’ll quickly find that budgeting is one of the more common topics of discussion. From Dave Ramsey and the envelope system to You Need A Budget (YNAB) software, budgeting is often portrayed as a required element for anyone to achieve a degree of financial success.
If you ask me (and you didn’t, but you’re reading this…so you kind of did), budgeting is a waste of time.
Unpaid Work
Unless you’re one of those poor souls that find a strange joy in accounting, creating and maintaining, your budget will always be a chore. It can never make or save you any money directly. You may say, “No, you’re wrong, my budget keeps me from spending more than I should in certain areas”. However, the budget didn’t do anything…you did. A budget is just a tool and nothing more. Now, some tools can certainly be helpful, but let’s not give them more credit than they deserve. And let’s be cognizant of tools that require more time and energy to use than the end result they provide, like a financial Rube Goldberg machine.
Band-aids on a stomach ache
A budget isn’t analogous to a life jacket or seatbelt: without one you can still be financially successful. Rather, it’s more like the ‘performance’ attire people wear in marathons: it makes you feel better, but the actual benefits are somewhat dubious.
Look, if you regularly smoke cigarettes, you don’t need a special app to tell you how many seconds of your life you lose with each puff. You know it’s bad already. The problem isn’t information, it’s action.
We all know people who, without fail, spend almost every last bit of their check each month. Their income doesn’t really matter; a similar situation exists across salary levels. Maybe you secretly love those people, because they allow you to pat yourself on the back and say “at least I’m not that bad.” And on the continuum of self-discipline, I suppose you are a few notches higher. However, comparing yourself to others is not a good recipe for success. You need to find the motivation to control your spending from within. I agree with the end goal of the budget, but like a band-aid on a stomach ache, it’s not the right tool for the job.
The facts are these:
- Only a small portion of your income is truly needed to pay for basic physical needs like food and shelter; the majority is discretionary spending, for your ‘wants’
- Despite mountains of evidence and anecdotes, we still falsely correlate money with happiness
- Material goods might provide a temporary boost in happiness, but it never lasts
I’m certainly not telling you anything you don’t already know above. So what’s the problem? Self-awareness and self-control.

Where to go from here
In every purchase decision you make, you need to have the self-awareness to recognize that you are fallible. You’re susceptible to marketing influence, the desire to impress others, and the falsehood that you can buy your way to contentment. Seeing yourself, the good/service, and the transaction for what they all are, you then need the self-control to decide if it is something that you really want and if not…walk away.
A budget is just a physical manifestation of a mind trick you play on yourself to try to spend less. You can cheat if you want, there are no repercussions. So unshackle yourself from the idea of a budget, and instead make every purchase a more thoughtful decision. Short circuit that mind trick, and get to the goal of having a budget without the pain of creating and keeping one.
